
In this post Iain Travers considers the impact of the Bill on mediation.
The Renters Rights Bill will be back in the House of Lords in October for its final stages before Royal Assent. Secondary legislation will be required to bring into force many of the provisions of the Bill. The guidance issued by the Government on the operation of the new legislation includes a number of references to the use of alternative dispute resolution. At a time when mediation is becoming a more established part of the dispute resolution process, it is worth examining whether the Bill does enough to help both landlords and tenants resolve their disputes.
For example, a landlord will be able to increase the rent once per year to the price that would be achieved if the property was newly advertised to let. If the tenant believes the proposed rent increase exceeds market rate, the increase can be challenged in the First Tier Tribunal, which will determine whether the rent demanded by the landlord is the market rent. The new rent will only apply from the date of the Tribunal determination. The guidance contains no reference to this crucial aspect of the relationship between landlord and tenant being capable of being resolved by mediation, and it is far from clear whether mediation will be part of the FTT process.
Although landlords will be expected to fund the proposed Ombudsman, they will not be able to use the Ombudsman to complain about their tenants. Only tenants will be able to seek redress from the Ombudsman. The Government has said that it is committed to ensuring that landlords, and tenants, have appropriate access to alternative dispute resolution, and that it is exploring options for landlord-initiated mediation, but there is no substance to the commitment.
The Government says that it expects its reforms to reduce demands on the Court system because only cases where there is a clear, well-evidenced ground for possession will be able to proceed. The Government has also said that it wants to ensure that disputes can be resolved before they escalate to Court, and that the Ministry of Justice is exploring options for early dispute resolution. Again, however, there is no substance in the Government’s guidance on how mediation might be used to find workable solutions for parties that find themselves in dispute.
Is this therefore a missed opportunity? The Property Mediators have enormous experience in resolving disputes of this nature, and we would welcome feedback from both sides of the residential letting sector as to whether they feel that the Government is doing enough to promote the use of alternative dispute resolution in this fundamental area which affects the lives and livelihoods of so many people and organisations.